>>132848963A better example would have been QB claiming it can't manipulate humans into doing what it wants when it is blatantly doing so for the entire series.
>>132849354A) the only metagamed wish in the series was Madoka's at the end
B) If you paid attention you'd remember that the world wasn't going to be destroyed in the first iteration when Homura made her wish.
C) Humans do not run on pure logic 100% of the time like machines . I have actually been diagnosed with aspergers and I understand that so why is that so hard for so many people to understand?
D) Madoka was her first friend after being in a long period of isolation. She got attached.
TLDR she was overly emotional and distraught when she made the wish she could have said anything else.
Your none of this happened wish example is just blatantly going to backfire. That's just one of the worst wishes you could possibly give to any sort of wish granter as there is a near infinite amount of ways in which it can/will go wrong.
