>>120344426Because any hazily and poorly defined metric you want for what constitutes "best ADC" still has to have, at the bottom line, the ability to win games.
Chinese ADCs play differently from Korean ADCs, who play different from EU, etc. Expectations are different, aggression, etc. Know what makes an ADC work with a team? When they win games.
Let me cut off two of your "counterpoints" right off the bat. First, when team strategies focused on Doubleshit CLG was not almost relegated once, but TWICE (had saint not shitpicked in the final game you'd be talking about his "potential" on a challenger team instead). It has only been when ADC role as a whole has the lowest game impact in any point in LoL history that "suddenly" CLG becomes a better team.
Second, Doublelift alone has "survived" muiltiple metas, multiple teams, multiple LCSes, etc. and yet every SINGLE time its always "everyone else's fault but his" when something goes wrong. This has been true for nearly 5 years. It will continue to be true for another 5.
It isn't an act. He really is that fucking awful.